12/10/2015 CONSERVATION COMMISSION Minutes

Home Browse Search

6:15 Jonathan J. Small and Jayne M. Singer, 40 Sturgis Larne. Proposed access NO[ staircase to existing deck and removal/reconstruction of walkover structure with seasonal pier. Resource Area: Matt Creighton, BSC Group, was present representing the applicants. He explained the proposed project is the removal of an existing dilapidated walkover structure and construction of a new walkover structure with seasonal, removal pier into Mashpee Pond: He noted the existing walkover is unusable and the old owners created a small path leading down to the pond. The proposed project would remove the existing structure and allow the existing vegetation to reestablish. The structure will be removed by hand so not to disturb the soil on the bank. The proposed structure is 4' wide and 40' long with a 4' by 8' T-end for storage. Matt Creighton stated he has submitted a mitigation plan totaling a required 80 s.f. which was determined using the Town of Mashpee regulations but is providing 300 square feet of mitigation. The Agent noted everything being proposed has no issue from the stairway down to the walkway. He noted historically the commission has not allowed in excess of 4 feet for platforms but it is at their discretion. Mitigation has been proposed for that situation. There is no vegetation where the platform is proposed. Every other part is in line with the regulations and meets the performance standards. There was a discussion on the removal of the float and the Agent noted this could be conditioned. Following a lengthy discussion regarding the placement of the stairs and platform, Motion: Mr. Gurnee moved to Close and Issue, seconded by Mr. Shaw. Mr. Gurnee, no, Mr. Rogers, no, Mr, McKay no, Mr. Anderson, no. Mr. Shaw yes. Vote 1-4 motion failed Motion: Mr. Gurnee moved to approve the plan as presented except for the unit storage area and replace it with a 4' by 4' platform at the base of the stairs and supporting the ramp down to the dock, seconded by Mr.Shaw. Vote unanimous. 5-0 Matt requested that the mitigation be taken out because it is not required. The commissioners agreed that would be his right as it is not required. The Agent asked for a revised plan. He reminded the commissioners that a letter from Natural Heritage is required before they issue an order of conditions. 6:18 James 1. and Ellen B. Goodman, 120 Summersea Road. Proposed NGl demolition/reconstruction of single-family dwelling, removal/reconstruction of walkover structure and pier with seasonal ramp and float, removal/reconstruction of shed. Resource Area: